Digital leasing has widened the fraud problem
Multifamily operators are shifting application screening toward centralized, technology-led decisions as fraud grows alongside online leasing. At OPTECH 2026 in Las Vegas, executives described systems that use artificial intelligence to flag risk while giving qualified applicants a faster path through the process. The goal is to make screening more consistent without turning every application into a slow, manual investigation.
Nearly 25% of apartment applicants this summer used fraudulent Social Security numbers, according to Austen Mount, managing director of operations at TruAmerica Multifamily. That figure points to a problem that’s followed the sector’s move to digital leasing, though the source of the number and the precise screening method aren’t detailed here. Dom Beveridge, principal of Houston-based consulting and research firm 20for20, said executives began naming fraud prevention as a major priority about three years ago.
The rise became especially visible during the COVID-19 pandemic, when online leasing expanded and eviction moratoriums were in effect. Beveridge said fraud increased at apartment communities nationwide, with Southern California and Atlanta among the areas where operators saw it. Easier digital access can cut friction for legitimate renters while also making it easier to submit fraudulent applications, a tension that sits at the center of the screening debate.
Screen for risk without slowing every applicant
Vendors moved quickly to develop tools for verifying applicants, and Beveridge said fraud prevention technology gained adoption faster than many other property management systems. As firms shifted administrative work away from onsite teams, they also built more systematic screening processes. That shift can help standardize decisions across locations, but it puts more weight on how a company defines risk and handles cases that don’t fit a routine pattern.
Yet application fraud accounts for only part of the risk behind bad debt, Beveridge cautioned. He sees a costly weakness in applying every check to every applicant, regardless of risk. That approach adds time and expense, and can make the leasing experience worse for applicants who pass screening readily. It may also direct staff attention toward routine files instead of cases that warrant closer review.
His preferred model gives lower-risk prospects a faster route while applying more scrutiny where the checks indicate a need. The operational challenge is to distinguish those groups consistently, rather than treating every application as if it carries the same risk. That requires a screening process that can explain why an application receives additional attention, while leaving room for a person to review an unusual circumstance. A faster path is useful only if the underlying decisions remain sound.
Centralized decisions put distance between leasing and screening
Western Wealth Communities initially considered assigning screening to a small group of specialists. Marlana Murdock, the firm’s vice president of property performance, said she favored three subject matter experts managing the process instead of 40 employees at 40 locations. The proposed arrangement would have concentrated responsibility, potentially making it easier to apply a common approach across properties.
As vendors introduced more capable tools, the company changed course and opted to automate screening through a third party using artificial intelligence. Leasing staff explain the process to applicants, while the screening provider handles the assessment. A declined applicant can still request a human review, with the reviewer able to override the automated decision. That division gives onsite staff a defined role in communicating the process while moving the initial assessment away from local leasing pressure.
Those exceptions are limited: Murdock said roughly one in 20 to one in 25 applicants returns to discuss an override. The case then goes to a person, such as Murdock, for a decision. The small share suggests that most cases proceed without an override, but it doesn’t show how often applicants accept an initial decision or what happens to those who don’t request a review.
Centralization also reduces the influence of onsite leasing teams, whose pressure to fill vacant units can complicate screening decisions. At Highmark Residential, overrides are rare, according to Jordan Ross, director of strategic initiatives. The team may reevaluate a case, but an override almost never follows. One exception can involve an applicant whose income comes solely from a trust, Ross said. That example illustrates why an automated result can’t always stand alone: a source of income that’s less straightforward to assess may call for human judgment.
What the shift means for renters and operators
The operating model emerging from these examples combines automated screening with human review for unusual cases. Its appeal is clear: centralized systems can limit differences between properties, while a review route gives applicants a way to raise circumstances the initial assessment may not capture. And yet, the accounts shared at OPTECH don’t establish that automation alone reduces fraud or bad debt. They describe how operators are reorganizing decisions as they respond to those risks.
For operators, the practical test is whether the screening process can be applied consistently and whether staff know when a case should be escalated. For applicants, the experience depends on more than the speed of an initial decision; the availability and handling of a review matter too. If you’re working in this space, the distinction between a fast process and a fair one deserves close attention. (And this is the part most people overlook.) A review option has value only if applicants can understand how to use it and a reviewer can meaningfully reconsider the case.
This is more significant than it looks. When screening moves away from individual leasing offices, companies are changing who makes consequential decisions about access to housing, as well as how those decisions are explained. The approach may reduce the effect of local pressure to fill units, but it also makes the quality of the screening rules and review process central to the outcome. Consistency matters. So does the ability to recognize an exception.
As vendors and management firms gain experience, the test will be whether they can keep legitimate applicants moving quickly while applying closer scrutiny to applications that raise concerns. The reported examples show a direction of travel, not a settled answer: automation for the initial assessment, with people available for cases that need another look. Whether that balance works will depend on how reliably firms identify risk and how carefully they handle the applicants who fall outside the ordinary pattern.